LED vs CFL vs Incandescent

A couple of decades ago, the only bulbs that were present to light homes were incandescent bulbs and the only choice you had to make was wattage, where you would pick a bulb based on the level of brightness needed.

In recent years, however, new bulbs have emerged due to advancements in technology hence replacing the old incandescent bulbs.

The new bulbs are CFLs and LEDs which are more energy-efficient and durable, meaning that they can last for many years. LED light bulbs were very expensive when they were discovered but their prices have declined significantly over the years.

In this article, the three types of bulbs; LEDs, CFLs, and incandescent will be explored in terms of their pros and cons hence answering the question, which one is better?

 

Everything You Need to Know about LEDs

led vs cfl efficiency

What Is LED?

LEDs that stand for Light-emitting Diodes were commonly found on clocks and other small electronic displays for some years before household LED bulbs came into existence a few years ago.

LED light bulbs create light energy when the positively and negatively charged electric current meets.

Initially, LEDs could only be used in indicator lights and lab equipment because they were able to emit red light only, but today they can produce ultraviolet and infrared spectrums that are visible.

The light released by these bulbs is reliable, spontaneous, and can be dimmed.

LEDs differ from CFLs and incandescent by the fact that they last for many years. Their lifespan is about 20000-50000 hours. Due to their efficiency and durability LEDs have been selling at higher prices compared to those of CFLs and incandescent.

However as stated earlier, their prices have dropped significantly over the years. LED bulbs once came as long tubes only but currently, they are available in all shapes and sizes and some also come with decorating ropes.


Pros of LEDs

  • Longevity: Since LEDs have a lifespan of about 20,000-50,000 hours, they can last up to 25 times and 5 times more than the standard incandescent bulb and CFLs respectively.
  • Efficiency: LEDs do not produce heat unlike the CFLs and incandescent bulbs. This way they can save much energy as air conditions are not needed.  Also, leds require low costs of maintenance.

A LED bulb of 16.5 watts has an energy usage equivalent to that of a 75-watt incandescent bulb and 20-watt CFL. It is predicted that if LEDs are adopted fully, it will lead to energy savings worth about $265 billion and a decline in demand for lighting electricity by 33% in 2027.

  • Instant Light: They light up instantly just like the incandescent bulbs.
  • Safe: They are not sensitive to cold temperatures and they contain no mercury.
  • Colored: They produce light of high quality available in various hues.

Cons of LED light Bulbs

  • LED light bulbs emit directional light hence not evenly spread as compared to other light sources.
  • LEDs are expensive. They have much higher upfront costs compared to other light sources. However, their prices are falling significantly over time and you can save much energy in the long run.

Where Are LEDs Commonly Used?

LEDs were first used in computer circuit boards. Currently, they are used in many other areas such as traffic lights, indoor and outdoor lighting as well as in lighted signs.

LEDs have been an exceptional solution for lighting schools, gymnasiums, commercial buildings, warehouses, roads, parking lots, and also large public areas.

 

Info about Compact Fluorescent Light

cfl and led difference

What Is CFL?

CFLs which stand for Compact fluorescent lights are tubes or bulbs that are filled with gases such as argon and mercury vapor and are lit when an electric current flows through the tube.

The reaction that takes place produces an invisible UV light and heat that is quickly changed to visible light through the help of the fluorescent coating inside the tube. This process takes a while and that is why a CFL bulb takes about 30 seconds to light up completely.

The standard fluorescent lights come in form of tubes and they were made to replace the incandescent bulbs since they are more long-lasting and efficient.


Pros of CFLs

  • Efficiency: CFLs use less energy than incandescent bulbs and they are about 4 times more efficient. This means that the wattage of a CFL bulb when multiplied by four would give the wattage of an equivalent incandescent bulb in terms of energy consumption.
  • Longevity: CFLs bulbs have an average lifespan of about 10,000 to 15,000 hours. Their lifespan is about 10 times greater than that of incandescent bulbs.
  • Price: CFLs cost much less than LED lights. Their prices have dropped dramatically since the first time they were brought to the market. They cost just a little more than the incandescent bulbs but they last longer.

 Cons of CFLs

  • They contain mercury. The mercury inside these bulbs is toxic and hence hazardous to the environment. This mercury poses a waste disposal challenge when their lifespan is over.
  • Their lifespan can drop below 10,000 hours when they are switched on and off so frequently.
  • CFLs lights are omnidirectional. These bulbs produce light at 360 degrees meaning that almost half of the light is wasted since it does not illuminate the desired areas.
  • CFLs are not dimmable and they have a sensitivity to extreme temperatures.
  • Take longer warm-up to light fully.

Where Are CFLs Commonly Used?

CFLs are commonly used in a wide range of areas such as warehouses, commercial buildings, and schools. They are also a perfect replacement for incandescent bulbs.

 

Before Buying Incandescent Light

difference between led and incandescent

What Is Incandescent?

An incandescent light bulb is a device that heats a filament or a wire using electricity until it glows white.

This filament cannot be heated in the presence of oxygen because it would burn up completely before it gets that hot to glow. The inert gases or the vacuum inside the incandescent bulbs make it possible for this filament to heat up to the level of glow.

The incandescent bulb burns out in the long run because the filament evaporates gradually with time. The molecules of the evaporated filament are deposited on the glass shell and hence a bulb that burns out will look yellow.

The incandescent bulb was originally discovered by Henry Woodward and Mathew Evans who later sold the patent to Thomas Edison. Thomas Edison then switched the bulb to a carbon filament.


Pros of Incandescent

  • Have a lower initial cost and therefore they are less expensive compared to the other two types of bulbs.
  • These bulbs can be dimmed with rheostats.
  • They have warmer color than the fluorescent bulbs.
  • They produce relatively high light output.
  • They can be dimmed or controlled and are easily installed.
  • Incandescent bulbs light up immediately and hence they do not take much time like fluorescent bulbs.
  • They have no toxic materials such as mercury, unlike the CFL bulbs.

Cons of Incandescent bulbs

  • A lifespan of about 1000 hours.
  • They emit heat and hence air conditioners are required to lower the temperatures. These air conditioners lead to an extra cost of energy.
  • Produce low lumen per watt.
  • Require high operating costs.

Where are Incandescent bulbs Commonly Used?

Incandescent bulbs are commonly used to light up small areas. They are used in table lamps, closets, car headlamps, hallway lighting, and desk lamps.

They are generally used to light commercial buildings and households. They can also be used for decoration and advertisement purposes.

 

Which Is Better: LED vs CFL vs Incandescent?

led vs incandescent heat

To know your better lighting bulb, the following aspects need to be compared before making the final verdict:

– Brightness

The decision to buy the right bulb will be effective based on whether you know the differences between the three types of bulbs in terms of their brightness. These bulbs vary significantly in terms of their light output.

Their brightness has to be measured in lumens for you to quantify their actual differences. Higher lumens indicate a greater brightness and lower lumens indicate the contrary.

The bulbs’ brightness is effectively measured by comparing this brightness with the amount of power it consumes.

Using the same amount of power, LEDs are the brightest when compared to CFLs and incandescent.


– Lumens and Wattage

The measurement for brightness is in lumens and is always compared with the wattage consumed to quantify it.

While both LED and CFL produces the same brightness, the amount of energy consumed to emit equal lumens differs significantly.

An incandescent bulb will emit 15 lumens of brightness using one watt of power while a CFL and LED will emit 60 lumens and 72 lumens respectively using the same amount of power.

This indicates that for just approximately 10 watts of power, a LED bulb will produce the same brightness as an incandescent bulb of 60 watts.


– Light Colors/Color Temperature

Color temperature is used to describe the visible light characteristics produced by different light emitters.

  • An incandescent bulb filament glows with different colors as its temperatures increase gradually. The colors of the glowing filament transition from red (warm color temperature) to orange then to yellow then to white. It doesn’t reach the cool color temperature; light blue.
  • The color temperatures for LEDs span from warm yellow to cool light blue.
  • Those of CFLs span from warm white to daylight.

– Lifespan

The lifespan of LED, CFL, and incandescent bulbs vary significantly. The advancement in technology has dramatically increased the lifespan of some light sources especially LED to very high levels.

Some LED bulbs last forever. Having a LED bulb with a lifespan of more than 25,000 hours means that if such a bulb stays on for 2 hours daily, 34 years will elapse before you can replace it.

Incandescent bulbs and CFLs have an average lifespan of 1,000 and 10,000 hours respectively.

If lifespan is the factor to consider when buying a light bulb, then LED bulbs are a perfect choice.


– Cost and Energy Efficiency

It is without a doubt that LEDs are the most energy-efficient among the three types of bulbs.  This is because while CFLs will consume about 25-35% less energy than incandescent bulbs, LEDs will consume about 75% less energy compared to the same incandescent bulbs.

Additionally, most of the energy released by CFLs and incandescent are in form of heat while LEDs produce no heat. In terms of cost, the upfront prices for the LEDs are much higher compared to the other two, but you will save a lot in the long run because they are rarely replaced as compared to the CFLs and the incandescent. LEDs also use the least power wattage among the three.

 

The Best Energy-Efficient Bulb Recommended on the Market

Photo Title Buy
LE LED Light...image LE LED Light Bulbs, 60W Equivalent 5000K Daylight White Non-Dimmable, A19 E26 Standard Medium Base, UL Listed, 8.5 Watt, Pack of 5 Buy On Amazon
LE 100W Equivalent...image LE 100W Equivalent LED Light Bulbs, 15W 1500 Lumens 5000K Daylight White Non-Dimmable, A19 E26 Standard Base, UL/FCC Listed, 11000 Hour Lifetime, Pack of 6 Buy On Amazon
Amazon Basics 60W...image Amazon Basics 60W Equivalent, Soft White, Non-Dimmable, 10,000 Hour Lifetime, A19 LED Light Bulb | 2-Pack, 60 Watt Buy On Amazon
GREAT EAGLE LIGHTING...image GREAT EAGLE LIGHTING CORPORATION A19 LED Light Bulb, 9W (60W Equivalent), UL Listed, 5000K (Daylight), 750 Lumens, Non-dimmable, Standard Replacement (4 Pack) Buy On Amazon
Ascher Vintage LED...image Ascher Vintage LED Edison Bulbs, 6W, Equivalent 60W, High Brightness Daylight White 4000K, ST58 Antique LED Filament Bulbs, E26 Medium Base, Non Dimmable, Clear Glass, Pack of 6 Buy On Amazon
Smart WiFi Light...image Smart WiFi Light Bulb, LED RGBCW Color Changing, Works with Alexa and Google Home Assistant, No Hub Required, A19 E26 Multicolor LUMIMAN 2 Pack Buy On Amazon
Great Eagle R30...image Great Eagle R30 or BR30 LED Bulb, 11W (75W Equivalent), 850 Lumens, Upgrade for 65W Bulb, 3000K Soft White Color, for Recessed Can Use, Wide Flood Light, Dimmable, and UL Listed (Pack of 6) Buy On Amazon
EMART Full Spectrum...image EMART Full Spectrum Light Bulb, 2 x 105W 5500K CFL Daylight for Photography Photo Video Studio Lighting Buy On Amazon
13 Watt CFL...image 13 Watt CFL Light Bulb (60 Watt) Soft White 2700K 1040LM Spiral Bulb Medium Base Compact Fluorescent Bulb (2 Pack) Buy On Amazon
PHILIPS LED PHILIPS...image PHILIPS LED PHILIPS 433557 100-watt Equivalent, Bright White (6500K) 23 Watt Spiral CFL Light Bulb, 4-Pack, Daylight Deluxe, 4 Count Buy On Amazon
GE 41032 Incandescent...image GE 41032 Incandescent Globe Soft White Bulbs, 75 Watts, 4/Pack Buy On Amazon
A19 Clear Incandescent...image A19 Clear Incandescent Rough Service Light Bulb, 60 Watt, 2700K Soft White, E26 Medium Base, 560 Lumens, 130V (6 Pack) Buy On Amazon
Antique Vintage Edison...image Antique Vintage Edison Bulb 4 Pack - 60 watt - Hudson Lighting 60 watt Vintage Light Bulb - ST58 - Squirrel Cage Filament - 230 Lumens - Dimmable - E26 Bulb Base – Edison Light Bulbs - Warm White Buy On Amazon

 

FAQs

1. Are CFLs or LEDs More Cost-Effective?

If you are looking for a long-term bulb or for large commercial/industrial spaces, LEDs absolutely wins.

When you want to replace your light bulb, the cost will certainly be the biggest factor in your decision making. But the cost is more than just the price. You should consider other options such as the length of operation.

A bit of money spent today might lead to substantial saving over the years. The buying price of LED bulbs is slightly more than that of CFL bulbs, but a 6 pack of LED bulbs will last you about 8 times longer than a 6 pack of CFL bulbs thus saving you money in the long run.

2. Do CFL or LED Bulbs Last Longer?

LED bulbs have an incredible lifespan.

They can last you up to 50,000 hours. In simpler terms, a string of LED lights in a particular holiday will still be functional for the next 40 holiday seasons.

CFL bulbs have a lifespan of about 10,000 hours thus cannot compare with the lifespan of LED lights. LED bulbs can fall on your floor and will not break, but CFL bulbs are fragile.

3. How Much Heat Do CFL and LED Bulbs Give off?

Your CFL bulb will use between 25-35% less energy compared to the traditional bulbs. This is good, but not the best. On the other hand, LED bulbs use 75% less energy compared to traditional bulbs thus amazingly energy efficient.

Moreover, CFL bulbs release about 80% of their energy to the surrounding as heat while your LED bulbs emit little or no energy thus extending their efficiency.

4. What Is the Difference between Fluorescent and LED Lights?

Fluorescent bulbs and LED bulbs produce light in entirely different methods. Different technologies are applied to have the two light bulbs function effectively as intended.

  • While LEDs are dependent on solid-state technology, fluorescent bulbs have mercury vapor and inert gases such as argon enclosed in a glass casing.
  • LEDs produce light through electromagnetic radiations while fluorescent bulbs emit ultraviolet radiations that are converted to visible light with the help of the phosphor coating inside the glass casing.

5. Why Would LEDs Put Fluorescent Lights out of Business?

The efficiency of LEDs is improving at a very high rate over the years and has beaten that of fluorescent bulbs in the recent past. This means that LEDs will remove the fluorescent lights out of business shortly.

Fluorescent lights are less efficient than LEDs because of several factors. First of all, fluorescent lights depend on a ballast to function but this ballast gets damaged at times leading the bulb to make some irritating noise.

Another inefficiency of fluorescent lights is that they pose a waste disposal challenge due to their dependence on mercury. Fluorescent lights also produce non-directional light.

6. Why Would LEDs Put CFLs out of Business?

The efficiency of CFLs is good but that of LEDs is even exceptional.

This means that as far as CFLs will last, LEDs will last much longer hence a time will come when CFLs will no longer be in business when their efficiency is entirely masked by that of LEDs.

The fact that CFLs depend on mercury which causes a waste disposal challenge is enough reason to replace them with the high efficient LEDs.

Furthermore, CFLs make some annoying noise when they are operating on damaged ballasts.

CFLs also emit non-directional light which leads to wastage. For instance, when CFLs illuminate the undesired areas such as the ceiling, much light energy is wasted. The fact that CFLs have these loopholes is an obvious indicator that they will not stay long in the market.

7. Should I Replace CFL with LED?

Replacing CFL with LED is essential even though the energy savings you are going to get is not as much as when replacing the incandescent bulbs with LEDs.

However, even as much as saving energy is the primary goal of replacing the types of bulbs you use, the other CFL inefficiencies discussed before are convincing enough for you to replace them.

Such inefficiencies are the warming-up period that you have to wait before the CFL bulb lights up completely.

 

Conclusion

In conclusion, It is very essential to embrace the change that advances in technology have caused. This is not only because we want to save some energy, but also because in a few years from now we shall not be able to buy some types of bulbs we use in our homes.

The incandescent bulbs in 10 years from now will probably be gone entirely, and only a few CFLs will be in the market. However, there is no need to worry because their replacement; the LED bulbs are much more durable and efficient.